Engineering · Unit 3 · QCAA sample IA2 All sample IA2 questions
QCAA sample IA2 · Section 2 · Calculation

Question 25

[6 marks] Complex unfamiliar (est.)

Your teacher writes your IA2. This is the QCAA sample, so use it for the question shapes, and ask your teacher for practice that matches your school’s paper.

The question [6 marks]

A truss is shown.

50 kN3.5 m3.5 m3.5 m3.0 m90 kNZ
Redrawn from the QCAA sample.

Calculate the force in member Z and identify whether the member is in tension or compression. Include a force diagram to support your response.

Watch the solution first

Cut through Z, keep one piece, then take moments where the other members meet

The truss is labelled and cut, then the left piece slides away with its cut members drawn pulling on it. Watch which forces drop out of each moment equation, and what happens to an arrow if its force comes out negative.

50 kN90 kNZ3.5 m3.5 m3.5 m3.0 mABCDEFGHIcutRL RL  = 55 kN3.5 m5.25 m10.5 m55 kNjoint 1joint 2FAF FFG  (Z)FDG 3.0 m1.75 mhalf a panel, not 3.5 m59.7°3.5 m3.0 m64.2 kN compression3.0 mZ sin 59.7°63.7 kN compressionRL = 55 kN ↑θ = 59.7°FAF = −64.2 kNZ = −63.7 kNZ = 63.7 kN, compressionMark 1Mark 2Mark 3Mark 4Mark 5Mark 6Label the spaces A to I. Cut through AF, FG (Z) and DGAbout the right support: 0 = −(90 × 3.5) − (50 × 5.25) + (RL  × 10.5), RL  = 55 kN ↑Keep the left piece. Draw the three cut members pulling on itZ rises 3.0 m over 1.75 m: θ = tan−1(3.0 ÷ 1.75) = 59.7°Moments about joint 2: 0 = (55 × 3.5) + (FAF  × 3), FAF  = −64.2 kNMoments about joint 1: 0 = (FAF  × 3) − (Z sin 59.7° × 3.5), Z = −63.7 kNNegative, so Z pushes on the piece. Z is in compressionZ = 63.7 kN in compression

A blue arrow pulls on the piece, which is the tension assumption. An orange arrow pushes on it, which is compression.

Now for the engineering

Choose the cut, the piece and the equation

Four cuts are drawn across the truss. Choose one, choose which piece to keep, then choose an equation and see which unknown forces it contains. Joint 1 is the left support and joint 2 is the bottom joint next to it. Then try each slip below to see what it does to the answer.

3.5 m3.5 m3.5 m3.0 m 50 kN90 kN Z joint 1 joint 2 a b c d 55 kN 85 kN
dashed: a cut blue, pointing away from the joint: pulling, tension assumed orange, pointing at the joint: pushing, compression
1. Choose a cut
2. Choose the piece to keep

Locked until you choose a cut.

3. Choose an equation

Locked until you choose a piece.

Try a common slip

QCAA sample marking scheme · 6 marks

Work through the solution one mark at a time

Try each step yourself before you reveal it. The sample scheme takes two moment equations. One sum of vertical forces also gives Z, so there are two methods.

Choose a method

Method 1 · Two moment equations
Step 1 · Label and cutMark 1

Label the spaces with Bow’s notation. A and B are above the truss, on each side of the 50 kN load. C and D are below it, on each side of the 90 kN load. E to I are the five triangles from left to right. Each member is named by the two spaces it separates, so Z is member FG.

Cut through the top member AF, through Z and through the bottom member DG. The cut passes through three members and the truss falls into two pieces.

50 kN3.5 m3.5 m3.5 m3.0 m90 kNZABCDEFGHIcut
Bow’s notation and the cut. Any clear labelling of the joints or the spaces will do.
Why?

A piece of a truss has three equations of equilibrium, so a cut through three members leaves three unknowns. The cut has to pass through Z, or Z never appears in an equation.

Marker: includes a truss labelling notation and applies a valid cut through Z

Step 2 · Left reactionMark 2

Take moments about the right support for the whole truss. The 90 kN load is 3.5 m from it and the 50 kN load is 5.25 m from it. Both turn the truss anticlockwise about that support. The left reaction $R_L$, 10.5 m away, turns it clockwise.

$$\begin{aligned}\Sigma M_R &= 0 \quad (\circlearrowright +) \\ 0 &= -(90 \times 3.5) - (50 \times 5.25) + (R_L \times 10.5) \\ R_L &= \frac{577.5}{10.5} = 55\ \text{kN} \uparrow\end{aligned}$$

Why?

The right reaction passes through the right support, so it has no moment about it. That leaves $R_L$ as the only unknown.

Note

The scheme’s marker line calls this reaction RA and its working calls it $R_L$. They are the same force, the reaction at the left support.

Marker: calculates the reaction force RA

Step 3 · Force diagram and angleMark 3

Keep the left-hand piece. The only outside force on it is $R_L$. Draw the three cut members as if in tension, so each arrow points away from the piece.

55 kNFAFFFG (Z)FDG59.7°3.0 m3.5 mjoint 2joint 1
The left-hand piece. I have called the left support joint 1 and the bottom joint next to it joint 2.

Z rises 3.0 m over half a panel, $3.5 \div 2 = 1.75$ m.

$$\theta = \tan^{-1}\!\left(\frac{3}{1.75}\right) = 59.7^\circ$$

Why?

The force diagram shows every force on the piece, so nothing is left out of an equation. Every unknown is assumed to be in tension, so a negative answer will mean compression.

Marking

Allow assumption of angle 60 degrees.

Allow assumption that all forces are in tension.

Marker: includes force diagram using method of sections and determines angle between base members

Step 4 · Top memberMark 4

Take moments about joint 2. Z and the bottom member both pass through it, so only $R_L$ and the top member remain. $R_L$ is 3.5 m to the left and turns the piece clockwise. The top member is 3.0 m above, and a pull to the right up there is also clockwise.

$$\begin{aligned}\Sigma M_2 &= 0 \quad (\circlearrowright +) \\ 0 &= (55 \times 3.5) + (F_{AF} \times 3) \\ F_{AF} &= -\frac{192.5}{3} = -64.2\ \text{kN}\end{aligned}$$

Negative, so the top member is in compression.

Why?

Taking moments about the joint where two unknown members meet removes both of them from the equation.

Note

The scheme writes this force as $-64.2$ kN tension and then as 64.2 kN compression. Those are the same statement: a negative answer under the tension assumption is a compression.

Marking

Allow method of joints working out.

Allow FT marks

Marker: calculates the force in member FAF

Step 5 · Force in ZMark 5

Now take moments about joint 1, the left support. $R_L$ and the bottom member pass through it. The top member is 3.0 m above it. Treat Z as acting at joint 2: its horizontal part passes through joint 1, and its vertical part, $Z\sin\theta$, is 3.5 m away. An upward force to the right of the point turns the piece anticlockwise.

$$\begin{aligned}\Sigma M_1 &= 0 \quad (\circlearrowright +) \\ 0 &= (F_{AF} \times 3) - (Z\sin 59.7^\circ \times 3.5) \\ Z &= \frac{-64.17 \times 3}{\sin 59.7^\circ \times 3.5} = -63.7\ \text{kN}\end{aligned}$$

Why?

A force can be moved along its line of action. At joint 2 the horizontal part of Z has no lever arm about joint 1, so only the vertical part is left.

Marker: calculates the force in member Z

Step 6 · Tension or compressionMark 6

The answer is negative, so Z pushes on the piece. Z is in compression.

Does it make sense? The reaction pushes the left-hand piece up with 55 kN, and nothing else on that piece acts vertically except Z. So Z must push down on it with a vertical part of 55 kN. A member that pushes is in compression.

$Z=63.7\text{ kN}$ in compression

Marker: determines member is in compression

Method 2 · Sum of the vertical forces
Step 1 · Label and cutMark 1

Label the spaces with Bow’s notation. A and B are above the truss, on each side of the 50 kN load. C and D are below it, on each side of the 90 kN load. E to I are the five triangles from left to right. Each member is named by the two spaces it separates, so Z is member FG.

Cut through the top member AF, through Z and through the bottom member DG. The cut passes through three members and the truss falls into two pieces.

50 kN3.5 m3.5 m3.5 m3.0 m90 kNZABCDEFGHIcut
Bow’s notation and the cut. Any clear labelling of the joints or the spaces will do.
Why?

A piece of a truss has three equations of equilibrium, so a cut through three members leaves three unknowns. The cut has to pass through Z, or Z never appears in an equation.

Marker: includes a truss labelling notation and applies a valid cut through Z

Step 2 · Left reactionMark 2

Take moments about the right support for the whole truss. The 90 kN load is 3.5 m from it and the 50 kN load is 5.25 m from it. Both turn the truss anticlockwise about that support. The left reaction $R_L$, 10.5 m away, turns it clockwise.

$$\begin{aligned}\Sigma M_R &= 0 \quad (\circlearrowright +) \\ 0 &= -(90 \times 3.5) - (50 \times 5.25) + (R_L \times 10.5) \\ R_L &= \frac{577.5}{10.5} = 55\ \text{kN} \uparrow\end{aligned}$$

Why?

The right reaction passes through the right support, so it has no moment about it. That leaves $R_L$ as the only unknown.

Note

The scheme’s marker line calls this reaction RA and its working calls it $R_L$. They are the same force, the reaction at the left support.

Marker: calculates the reaction force RA

Step 3 · Force diagram and angleMark 3

Keep the left-hand piece. The only outside force on it is $R_L$. Draw the three cut members as if in tension, so each arrow points away from the piece.

55 kNFAFFFG (Z)FDG59.7°3.0 m3.5 mjoint 2joint 1
The left-hand piece. I have called the left support joint 1 and the bottom joint next to it joint 2.

Z rises 3.0 m over half a panel, $3.5 \div 2 = 1.75$ m.

$$\theta = \tan^{-1}\!\left(\frac{3}{1.75}\right) = 59.7^\circ$$

Why?

The force diagram shows every force on the piece, so nothing is left out of an equation. Every unknown is assumed to be in tension, so a negative answer will mean compression.

Marking

Allow assumption of angle 60 degrees.

Allow assumption that all forces are in tension.

Marker: includes force diagram using method of sections and determines angle between base members

Step 4 · Top member, for the fourth markMark 4

The vertical sum in Step 5 does not need the top member. The sample scheme gives a mark for its force, so find it with one moment equation about joint 2, where Z and the bottom member meet.

$$\begin{aligned}\Sigma M_2 &= 0 \quad (\circlearrowright +) \\ 0 &= (55 \times 3.5) + (F_{AF} \times 3) \\ F_{AF} &= -\frac{192.5}{3} = -64.2\ \text{kN}\end{aligned}$$

Negative, so the top member is in compression.

Why?

Both routes are valid statics. If your teacher’s marking scheme rewards the top member force, as the sample does, show it.

Note

The scheme writes this force as $-64.2$ kN tension and then as 64.2 kN compression. Those are the same statement: a negative answer under the tension assumption is a compression.

Marking

Allow method of joints working out.

Allow FT marks

Marker: calculates the force in member FAF

Step 5 · Force in Z from the vertical forcesMark 5

The top and bottom members are horizontal. On the left-hand piece the only vertical forces are $R_L$ and the vertical part of Z.

$$\begin{aligned}\Sigma F_V &= 0 \quad (\uparrow +) \\ 0 &= 55 + Z\sin 59.7^\circ \\ Z &= \frac{-55}{\sin 59.7^\circ} = -63.7\ \text{kN}\end{aligned}$$

That is the same answer from one equation, without needing the top member at all.

Why?

A horizontal member has no vertical part, so the top and bottom members drop out of the vertical sum and Z is the only unknown.

Marker: calculates the force in member Z

Step 6 · Tension or compressionMark 6

The answer is negative, so Z pushes on the piece. Z is in compression.

Does it make sense? The reaction pushes the left-hand piece up with 55 kN, and nothing else on that piece acts vertically except Z. So Z must push down on it with a vertical part of 55 kN. A member that pushes is in compression.

$Z=63.7\text{ kN}$ in compression

Marker: determines member is in compression

Common errors

If I had to guess where you might lose marks…

  • Cutting through too many members. A slanted cut through Z can also pass through AF, GH, HI and CI. That is five unknowns for three equations of equilibrium, and no equation leaves Z on its own. Mark 1 is lost. Cut through Z and at most two other members: AF, Z and DG.
  • Measuring a lever arm from the wrong support. You take moments about the right support but use 7 m for the 90 kN load, its distance from the left support. Then $R_L=\dfrac{(90\times7)+(50\times5.25)}{10.5}=85$ kN, which is the right reaction, and Z comes out at $-98.4$ kN. Mark 2 is lost. Check that the two reactions add to $50+90=140$ kN. The 90 kN load is nearer the right support, so the right reaction has to be the larger one.
  • Taking the angle from 3.0 over 3.5. You get $\tan^{-1}(3\div3.5)=40.6^\circ$ and $Z=\dfrac{-55}{\sin40.6^\circ}=-84.5$ kN. Mark 3 is lost. Each top joint sits above the middle of a bottom panel, so Z rises 3.0 m over 1.75 m and the angle is $59.7^\circ$.
  • Reading the sign of Z backwards. You find $Z=-63.7$ kN and write 63.7 kN in tension. Mark 6 is lost. You drew Z pulling on the piece, so a negative answer means it pushes: compression. Check it against the piece. The 55 kN reaction pushes up, so Z has to push down.

Only mark this done when you could do it without help. Reading the solution does not count.

Back to the index

Question wording is from the QCAA Engineering 2025 v1.4 IA2 sample assessment instrument, and the marker lines are from its sample marking scheme, © State of Queensland (QCAA) 2026, licensed under CC BY 4.0. Figures are redrawn. The solutions, animations and commentary are Tangent Tuition’s. Tangent Tuition is not affiliated with the QCAA.