Mathematical Methods · Mock exam 2026 All mock exam questions
Mock exam · Paper 2 · Complex unfamiliar

Question 18

[5 marks] Technology-active
The question

A company sells hot water systems for $\text{\textdollar}4200$ each.

The lifetimes of the systems are normally distributed with a mean of 11 years.

Each system has a warranty. The warranty refunds the full price for systems failing within five years. It refunds half the price for systems failing between five and eight years.

It is known that 1.2% of the systems receive a full refund.

The company's accountant makes the following claim.

On average, warranty refunds will cost the company less than $\text{\textdollar}270$ for each system sold.

Evaluate the reasonableness of this claim.

[5 marks]
Before you look anything up

What the question doesn’t tell you

Have a go at the question cold first. When you are stuck, or finished, open the list and check which of these steps you found for yourself.

  1. The standard deviation is not given. The mean is 11 years, and the only other fact about the lifetimes is the 1.2%, so $\sigma$ has to come from that.
  2. A full refund happens exactly when a system fails within five years, so 1.2% is the left-tail area $P(X\lt5)=0.012$. Inverse normal turns it into a $z$-score, and $z=\dfrac{x-\mu}{\sigma}$ gives $\sigma$.
  3. A half refund is for a system that fails between five and eight years, so you need the area from 5 to 8, not the area below 8.
  4. You have to invent the refund for one system, $R$, as a discrete random variable with three values: $4200, $2100 and $0. Its probabilities sum to 1, which gives the third one.
  5. “On average” means expected value, $E(R)=\sum r\,P(R=r)$.
  6. The claim is a threshold of $270. Compare the expected refund with it and state a decision about the claim.
Watch the solution first

One tail fixes the curve, three zones price the refund

The 1.2% pins down the spread of the curve. Its three refund zones become a table, and the expected refund is measured against the claimed $270.

058111520lifetime (years)mean 111.2%: full refund: half refund: no refund standard normal01.2% z = −2.2571 5 − 11σ= −2.2571 σ = 2.658 r ($)P(R = r)420021000fullhalfnone 0.0120 0.1175 0.8705 $0$100$200$300 50.40 246.75 0 E(R) = 297.15 50.40246.75 claim: less than $270 Mark 1 Mark 2 Mark 3 Mark 4 Mark 5 mean 11 years, σ unknown 5 − 11σ= −2.2571, so σ = 2.658 P(5 < X < 8) = 0.1175 the refund is a discrete random variable E(R) = 50.40 + 246.75 + 0 = 297.15 297.15270= 1.1006, about 10% more Expected refund about $297 for each system, more than $270.The claim is not reasonable.
Now for the mathematics

Price the warranty seven ways

Choose a preset to draw the lifetime curve, shade its three refund zones and set the expected refund against the dashed $270 line. The first three are accepted working. The last four are common slips.

Accepted working
Common slips
Lifetime curve
mean 11 058111520 σ not known yet: choose a preset
Lifetime (years)
full refund (solid) half refund (hatched) no refund (dotted)
curve with
curve with
correct curve
used for the half refund
Expected refund
off the scale $0$100$200$300$400 $270 claim

Only the mean is fixed so far. Pick a preset above to find , shade the three refund zones and see the expected refund for that set of working.

The expected refund is more than $270, so the claim is not reasonable. This is the working in the marking steps below.

Rounding $\sigma$ to 2.7 moves the half-refund probability to 0.1201, but $302.66 is still more than $270. The conclusion is the same, so this rounding is accepted.

Recalculating the full refund with $\sigma=2.7$ as well moves it to 0.01313 and the expected refund to $307.43. That is still more than $270, so this is accepted too.

$P(X\lt8)$ also includes every system that fails within five years, so the full-refund systems are counted a second time, at $2100 as well as $4200. The verdict happens to match, but this loses Mark 2. The later marks can still be earned by follow-through.

Without the full refund the expected refund drops to $246.75, below $270, so the claim wrongly looks reasonable. This loses Mark 3. The comment is then marked by follow-through.

With only the full refund the expected refund is $50.40, so the claim wrongly looks reasonable. The half refunds are the larger cost. This loses Marks 2, 3 and 4. The comment is then marked by follow-through.

Reading 1.2% as 0.12 makes the tail ten times too big, so $\sigma$ grows to 5.106 and every later value is wrong. This loses Mark 1.

Marking guide · 5 marks

Work through the solution one mark at a time

Try each step yourself before you reveal it.

Step 11 mark

Let $X$ be the lifetime (years) of a system. $X$ is normally distributed with mean 11 and standard deviation $\sigma$. A full refund means $X\lt5$, so 1.2% is a left-tail area.

$$P(X\lt5)=0.012$$

$$P(Z\lt z)=0.012\Rightarrow z=-2.2571$$

$$\dfrac{5-11}{\sigma}=-2.2571$$

$$\sigma=2.658$$

Why?

The mean is given but the standard deviation is not, and the 1.2% is the only other fact about the lifetimes. Inverse normal turns that area into a $z$-score, and the $z$-score formula gives $\sigma$.

Calculator use

Use inverse normal with a left-tail area of 0.012, mean 0 and standard deviation 1 to get $z=-2.2571$. Store $\sigma$ unrounded and use the stored value from here on.

Marking

Rounding $\sigma$ to 2.7 is accepted. It gives an expected refund of about $303 to $307, which supports the same conclusion.

Marker: correctly determines the standard deviation of the lifetimes

Step 21 mark

A half refund is for a system that fails between five and eight years, so its probability is the area from 5 to 8 under $X\sim N\!\left(11,\ 2.658^2\right)$.

$$P(5\lt X\lt8)=0.1175$$

Calculator use

Use normal cdf with lower 5, upper 8, mean 11 and the stored $\sigma$.

Marking

Using $P(X\lt8)=0.1295$ for the half refund does not gain this mark, because it counts the full-refund systems a second time. It leads to about $322. The remaining marks can still be earned by follow-through.

Marker: correctly determines the probability that a system receives a half refund

Step 31 mark

Let $R$ be the refund ($\text{\textdollar}$) for a system. It takes only three values: the full price $4200, half the price $0.5\times4200=\text{\textdollar}2100$, or $0 for a system that lasts beyond eight years. So $R$ is a discrete random variable.

$$P(R=0)=1-0.0120-0.1175=0.8705$$

$$\begin{array}{c|c|c|c}r\ (\text{\textdollar})&4200&2100&0\\\hline P(R=r)&0.0120&0.1175&0.8705\end{array}$$
Why?

The probabilities of a discrete random variable must sum to 1, which gives the third probability.

Marking

Leaving out the full refund gives about $247 and does not gain this mark. The final comment can still be earned by follow-through.

Marker: recognises that the refund for a system is a discrete random variable and correctly determines its probability distribution

Step 41 mark

“On average” means the expected value.

$$\begin{aligned}E(R)&=4200(0.0120)+2100(0.1175)\\&\quad+0(0.8705)\\&=297.15\end{aligned}$$

Why?

For a discrete random variable, $E(R)=\sum r\,P(R=r)$. Here that is $50.40+246.75+0$.

Marking

Including only the full refund gives about $50. That response does not gain this mark, or the second and third marks. The final comment can still be earned by follow-through.

Marker: determines the expected refund for each system

Step 51 mark

The claim is a threshold of $270, so compare the expected refund with it and state the decision.

$$\text{\textdollar}297.15>\text{\textdollar}270$$

$$\dfrac{297.15}{270}=1.1006$$

The expected refund is about $297 for each system sold, about 10% more than $270. The claim is not reasonable.

Marker: evaluates the reasonableness of the claim using a suitable comment

Common errors

If I had to guess where you might lose marks…

  • Reading 1.2% as 0.12. Inverse normal gives $z=-1.1750$, so $\sigma=5.106$, $P(5\lt X\lt8)=0.1584$ and $E(R)\approx\text{\textdollar}837$. This loses Mark 1, and every later value is wrong.
  • Using $P(X\lt8)=0.1295$ for the half refund. This counts the full-refund systems twice and gives $E(R)=50.40+2100(0.1295)\approx\text{\textdollar}322$. This loses Mark 2. Follow-through applies to the remaining marks.
  • Omitting the full refund. $E(R)=2100(0.1175)\approx\text{\textdollar}247$, which is less than $270, so the claim wrongly looks reasonable. This loses Mark 3. Follow-through applies to Mark 5.
  • Including only the full refund. $E(R)=4200(0.0120)\approx\text{\textdollar}50$, so the claim wrongly looks reasonable. This loses Marks 2, 3 and 4. Follow-through applies to Mark 5.
What makes this complex unfamiliar

The question gives you a price, a mean, a refund policy, one percentage and a claim, but no standard deviation, no random variable and no instruction to find an expected value. You have to see that the 1.2% is the left-tail area below 5 years, because a full refund happens exactly when a system fails within five years, and use it to find $\sigma$. Then you have to invent the refund for a system, $R$, as a discrete random variable whose probabilities come from three intervals of a normal distribution. The required procedure is not clear from the way the problem is posed.

Each piece on its own is routine Unit 3 and 4 work: an inverse normal, a normal probability, a probability distribution that sums to 1 and an expected value. What is unfamiliar is the chain. The words “on average” have to become $E(R)$, the half refund has to become the interval from 5 to 8 rather than everything below 8, and the question only asks you to evaluate a claim, so the comparison with $270 and the decision are yours to set up.

Only mark this done when you could do it without help. Reading the solution does not count.

Back to the index

A Tangent Tuition mock exam question. It is not a past QCAA question, and Tangent Tuition is not affiliated with the QCAA.