The random variable $X$ is normally distributed with $X\sim N(20,\,9)$.
The random variable $Y$ is normally distributed with $Y\sim N(24,\,4)$.
Select the correct statement.
Not quite. You read the second parameter as the standard deviation: $20+9=29$ and $24+4=28$. With $\sigma_X=3$ and $\sigma_Y=2$ these are $z=3$ and $z=2$, so $P(X<29)=0.9987$ but $P(Y<28)=0.9772$.
Not quite. You halved the variance instead of taking its square root (standard deviations $4.5$ and $2$): $20+4.5=24.5$ and $24+2=26$. The true $z$-scores are $1.5$ and $1$, so $P(X<24.5)=0.9332$ but $P(Y<26)=0.8413$.
Not quite. You added the same raw distance, $3$, to each mean: $23$ and $27$. The $z$-scores are $1$ and $1.5$, so $P(X<23)=0.8413$ but $P(Y<27)=0.9332$.
That is it. Step through the hints below to see why.
Solid curve: $X$, centred at 20. Dashed curve: $Y$, centred at 24, narrower and taller. Hatching shades $P(X<a)$ and dots shade $P(Y<b)$.
Choose an option to draw its two cut-offs, shade both probabilities and compare them.
For $X$: $a=29$, $z=3$, $P(X<29)=0.9987$
For $Y$: $b=28$, $z=2$, $P(Y<28)=0.9772$
Not equal.
9 and 4 are variances.
For $X$: $a=24.5$, $z=1.5$, $P(X<24.5)=0.9332$
For $Y$: $b=26$, $z=1$, $P(Y<26)=0.8413$
Not equal.
Variance halved, not square-rooted.
For $X$: $a=23$, $z=1$, $P(X<23)=0.8413$
For $Y$: $b=27$, $z=1.5$, $P(Y<27)=0.9332$
Not equal.
Same raw distance, different spreads.
For $X$: $a=23$, $z=1$, $P(X<23)=0.8413$
For $Y$: $b=26$, $z=1$, $P(Y<26)=0.8413$
Equal.
(A) puts the cut-offs 3 and 2 standard deviations above the means, so the two areas differ.
(B) puts the cut-offs 1.5 and 1 standard deviations above the means, so the two areas differ.
(C) puts the cut-offs 1 and 1.5 standard deviations above the means, so the two areas differ.
(D) puts both cut-offs 1 standard deviation above their means, so the areas are equal and it is the answer.
Try the question first. Choose a hint above when you want one.
$N(\mu,\sigma^{2})$ gives the variance, so
and
For $X$:
For $Y$:
So $P(X<23)=P(Y<26)$.
$P(X<a)=P(Y<b)$ exactly when $a$ and $b$ are the same number of standard deviations above their own means.
$\sigma_X=3$ and $\sigma_Y=2$. Both 23 and 26 are 1 standard deviation above their means ($z=1$), so $P(X<23)=P(Y<26)$.
Only mark this done when you could do it without help. Reading the solution does not count.
A Tangent Tuition mock exam question. It is not a past QCAA question, and Tangent Tuition is not affiliated with the QCAA.
Spot a mistake on this page? Report it