Engineering · Unit 3 · QCAA sample IA2 All sample IA2 questions
QCAA sample IA2 · Section 2 · Calculation

Question 23

[4 marks] Simple familiar (est.)

Your teacher writes your IA2. This is the QCAA sample, so use it for the question shapes, and ask your teacher for practice that matches your school’s paper.

The question [4 marks]

A cylindrical test specimen with an original length of 125 mm and a diameter of 10 mm is subjected to a tensile test shown in the graph.

0123456789101112131415161718192005101520253035404550Displacement (mm)Force (kN)
Redrawn from the QCAA sample.

Determine the Young’s modulus of the material.

Watch the solution first

Read one point on the straight part, then turn it into a stress and a strain

The graph is drawn as printed and the specimen is drawn to scale. Watch which part of the line is used, how one point is read off, and how the force and the stretch become a stress and a strain.

0123456789101112131415161718192005101520253035404550Displacement (mm)Force (kN)straight part30 kN9 mm39 kN at 13 mmgives 4.77 GPaF = 30 kN, ΔL = 9 mmσ = 381.97 MPaε = 0.072E = 5305 MPa = 5.31 GPaMark 1Mark 2Mark 3Mark 4125 mm10 mmA = π × 5² = 78.54 mm²stretch ΔL = 9 mmA tensile test on a specimen 125 mm long and 10 mm in diameterYoung’s modulus comes from the straight part of the line onlyRead one point on the straight part: F = 30 kN at ΔL = 9 mmσ = F/A = 30 000 ÷ (π × 5²) = 381.97 MPaε = ΔL/L = 9 ÷ 125 = 0.072E = σ/ε = 381.97 ÷ 0.072 = 5305 MPa = 5.31 GPaA point past the straight part gives a lower, wrong modulus: 4.77 GPaYoung’s modulus of the material: E = 5.31 GPa

The thick orange band is the straight part. The grey dotted line is a reading from the curved part, and it is the wrong one.

Now for the engineering

Slide the point you read along the line and watch the modulus

Use the slider to move the point you read off the graph. The force is read to the nearest 0.1 kN, and the specimen stays at 125 mm long and 10 mm in diameter. Watch what happens to $E$ as the point moves, then try each slip below to see what it does to the answer.

0123456789101112131415161718192005101520253035404550Displacement (mm)Force (kN)
thick band: the straight partdashed: your read-off linesdotted: from the origin through your point
Modulus from this point (GPa) 0123456
Try a common slip at 30 kN and 9 mm
✗ Used
✓ Correct

QCAA sample marking scheme · 4 marks

Work through the solution one mark at a time

Try each step yourself before you reveal it. The marking scheme accepts any valid point on the straight part, and it accepts a one-line formula as worth the last three marks, so there are two methods.

Choose a method

Method 1 · Stress, then strain
Step 1 · Read a point on the straight partMark 1

Young’s modulus is the gradient of the straight part of a stress against strain graph, so the point has to come from the straight part of this line. The straight part passes through the grid crossing at 30 kN and 9 mm. Change the force to newtons straight away.

$$F=30\text{ kN}=30\,000\text{ N}\qquad\Delta L=9\text{ mm}$$

Why?

On the straight part the force is proportional to the stretch. Past about 35 kN the line bends, and a point read there gives a lower value that is not Young’s modulus. A point where the line crosses a grid intersection is the easiest to read exactly.

Marking

Accept any valid force and change in length values obtained from the linear section of the graph.

Marker: interprets graph to identify a valid force and change in length

Step 2 · StressMark 2

The specimen is a cylinder, so its cross-section is a circle. The diameter is 10 mm, so the radius is 5 mm. Work in newtons and square millimetres so that the stress comes out in MPa.

$$\begin{aligned}\sigma&=\frac{F}{A}\\[6pt]&=\frac{30\,000}{\pi\times5^2}\\[6pt]&=381.97\text{ MPa}\end{aligned}$$

Why?

Stress is the force over the area it acts on. The area is $\pi\times5^2=78.54\text{ mm}^2$, and $1\text{ N/mm}^2=1\text{ MPa}$.

Marker: calculates stress value

Step 3 · StrainMark 3

Strain is the change in length over the original length. Both are in millimetres, so the units cancel.

$$\begin{aligned}\varepsilon&=\frac{\Delta L}{L}\\[6pt]&=\frac{9}{125}\\[6pt]&=0.072\end{aligned}$$

Why?

The displacement on the graph is how far the 125 mm specimen has stretched. Strain has no unit.

Marker: calculates strain value

Step 4 · Young’s modulusMark 4

Divide the stress by the strain. The stress is in MPa, so the answer is in MPa. Divide by 1000 for GPa.

$$\begin{aligned}E&=\frac{\sigma}{\varepsilon}\\[6pt]&=\frac{381.97}{0.072}\\[6pt]&=5305\text{ MPa}\\&=5.31\text{ GPa}\end{aligned}$$

The Young’s modulus of the material is $5.31\text{ GPa}$.
Marking

Allow FT marks

Marker: calculates Youngs Modulus

Method 2 · One-line formula
Step 1 · Read a point on the straight partMark 1

Young’s modulus is the gradient of the straight part of a stress against strain graph, so the point has to come from the straight part of this line. The straight part passes through the grid crossing at 30 kN and 9 mm. Change the force to newtons straight away.

$$F=30\text{ kN}=30\,000\text{ N}\qquad\Delta L=9\text{ mm}$$

Why?

On the straight part the force is proportional to the stretch. Past about 35 kN the line bends, and a point read there gives a lower value that is not Young’s modulus. A point where the line crosses a grid intersection is the easiest to read exactly.

Marking

Accept any valid force and change in length values obtained from the linear section of the graph.

Marker: interprets graph to identify a valid force and change in length

Step 2 · One line for Young’s modulusMark 2Mark 3Mark 4

Put $\sigma=\dfrac{F}{A}$ and $\varepsilon=\dfrac{\Delta L}{L}$ into $E=\dfrac{\sigma}{\varepsilon}$ and the three lines become one. The area is $\pi\times5^2=78.54\text{ mm}^2$. With newtons and millimetres the answer is in MPa.

$$\begin{aligned}E&=\frac{FL}{A\,\Delta L}\\[6pt]&=\frac{30\,000\times125}{78.54\times9}\\[6pt]&=5305\text{ MPa}\\&=5.31\text{ GPa}\end{aligned}$$

The Young’s modulus of the material is $5.31\text{ GPa}$.
Marking

Accept Youngs modulus calculated using the formula $E=\dfrac{FL}{A\Delta L}$ as three marks

Allow FT marks

Marker: calculates Youngs Modulus

Is the answer sensible?

A modulus of about 5 GPa is far too low for a metal and is in the range of a stiff polymer. The numbers here are for practice only. The same graph implies an elastic strain of more than 8%, which no real structural material shows. A check like that still tells you whether your powers of ten are sensible.

Common errors

If I had to guess where you might lose marks…

  • Reading the point from the curved part. You read the top of the curve, 39 kN at 13 mm, and get $E=\dfrac{39\,000\times125}{78.54\times13}$, which is $4775$ MPa or $4.77$ GPa. Mark 1 is lost, because the scheme accepts values from the linear section only. Read a point below 35 kN, where the line is still straight.
  • Using the diameter as the radius. You write $A=\pi\times10^2=314.16\text{ mm}^2$, so the stress is $95.49$ MPa and $E=1326$ MPa, which is $1.33$ GPa, a quarter of the answer. Mark 2 is lost. Halve the 10 mm first: $A=\pi\times5^2=78.54\text{ mm}^2$.
  • Leaving the force in kilonewtons. You get $\dfrac{30}{78.54}=0.382$ and call it MPa, so $E$ comes out as $5.31$ MPa. The digits look right because kN per mm² is GPa, but the unit is 1000 times out. Mark 2 is lost. Change 30 kN to $30\,000$ N before you divide.
  • Taking the strain over the stretched length. You divide by $125+9=134$ mm and get $\varepsilon=\dfrac{9}{134}=0.06716$, so $E=5687$ MPa, which is $5.69$ GPa. Mark 3 is lost. Strain is the change in length over the original length, $\dfrac{9}{125}=0.072$.
  • Skipping the change from MPa to GPa. $381.97\div0.072=5305$ is in MPa, because the stress was in MPa. If you write $5305$ GPa the answer is 1000 times too big and Mark 4 is lost. Write $5305$ MPa, or divide by 1000 for $5.31$ GPa.

Only mark this done when you could do it without help. Reading the solution does not count.

Back to the index

Question wording is from the QCAA Engineering 2025 v1.4 IA2 sample assessment instrument, and the marker lines are from its sample marking scheme, © State of Queensland (QCAA) 2026, licensed under CC BY 4.0. Figures are redrawn. The solutions, animations and commentary are Tangent Tuition’s. Tangent Tuition is not affiliated with the QCAA.