Your teacher writes your IA2. This is the QCAA sample, so use it for the question shapes, and ask your teacher for practice that matches your school’s paper.
The question [1 mark]
A simply supported beam is shown.
Redrawn from the QCAA sample.
Identify the effect of the applied force F on the length of the beam’s neutral axis X–X.
Watch the solution first
Draw a grid on the beam, bend it, then measure three fibres
Watch the lengths of the top fibre, the bottom fibre and the line X–X between them as the force grows. The bars under the beam show each fibre laid out straight.
The numbers are for a model beam, 4000 mm long and 400 mm deep, that bends into a circular arc. The bending is drawn far larger than a real beam’s so that you can see it.
Now for the engineering
Load the beam and measure three fibres
Raise the force and read the three lengths. Then swap the beam for a cantilever and load it again. After that, test each answer below against the model. The model beam is 4000 mm long and 400 mm deep, and it bends into a circular arc. Each unit of force turns its end faces a further 0.05 rad apart, which is far more than a real beam bends.
Compression: solid, arrows point inTension: dashed, arrows point outNeutral axis X–X: dash-dot
Choose the beam
Test an answer
UsedCorrect
QCAA sample marking scheme · 1 mark
Work through the solution one mark at a time
Write your own sentence before you reveal each step. There is one mark, and it is for one idea.
Step 1 · What bending does to the beamNo mark on its own
The force F makes the beam sag between its supports. The top of the beam is now on the inside of the curve, so its fibres are squeezed and get shorter. That is compression. The bottom is on the outside of the curve, so its fibres are stretched and get longer. That is tension.
Why?
The question is about one line inside the beam, so first sort out what happens above that line and below it.
Step 2 · The neutral axis X–XMark 1
Somewhere between a layer that is squeezed and a layer that is stretched there must be a layer that is neither. That layer is the neutral axis. It curves with the beam, but it is neither stretched nor squeezed, so its length does not change.
No effect: the neutral axis keeps its original length.
Why?
The question asks about length, so the safest answer names the length. The line you write on is one line long, so one sentence is all that is wanted.
Marking
Accept other suitable response consistent with a reasonable understanding.
Marker: identifies that the applied force will not affect the neutral axis of the beam
The model response in full
Force F has no effect on the beam’s neutral axis.Mark 1
That is the sample response in the marking scheme, and the scheme accepts other suitable responses. The question asks about length, so I would name the length: “No effect: the neutral axis keeps its original length.”
Common errors
If I had to guess where you might lose marks…
Saying the neutral axis gets longer. You are describing the fibre on the outside of the curve, which is in tension. In the model beam above, the bottom fibre is stretched from 4000 mm to 4100 mm. X–X curves too, but a line can curve without being stretched. You lose Mark 1.
Saying the neutral axis gets shorter. You are describing the fibre on the inside of the curve, which is in compression: 4000 mm down to 3900 mm in the model. Or you are picturing the ends of X–X moving closer together, 3958.5 mm apart in a straight line. Length is measured along the line, and that is still 4000 mm. You lose Mark 1.
Saying it does not bend. The neutral axis curves with the beam. In the model its midpoint ends up 248.7 mm below its ends. What does not change is its length, and the length is what the question asks about. An answer about the shape puts Mark 1 at risk, so name the length.
Describing the rest of the beam instead. “The top is in compression and the bottom is in tension” is true for this beam, but it never mentions X–X, so you have not answered the question. You lose Mark 1. The answer line is one line long, so write one sentence about the neutral axis and stop.
Only mark this done when you could do it without help. Reading the solution does not count.