First object: differentiate, $v_{1}=t^{2}-t+k$, so its initial velocity is $k$.
1 markThe first object's velocity.
Second object: integrate the acceleration, $v_{2}=4t+c$. "Towards each other with the same initial speed" is the hidden condition. Same speed but opposite direction means $v_{2}(0)=-k$, so $v_{2}=4t-k$.
1 markThe second object's velocity, including the constant.
1 markThe link between the constants, $c=-k$. Using $v_{1}(1)=v_{2}(1)$ to get $c=4-2k$ also works.
Equal velocities at $t=1$: $1-1+k=4-k$, so $k=2$. Now find the next time they are equal:
$$t^{2}-t+2=4t-2\ \Rightarrow\ t^{2}-5t+4=0\ \Rightarrow\ (t-1)(t-4)=0$$
1 markThe second time the velocities are equal, $t=4$.
So the interval is $1\le t\le4$. Both velocities are positive throughout ($t^{2}-t+2$ has no real roots, and $4t-2>0$ for $t>\frac12$), so distance equals displacement:
$$\int_{1}^{4}\left(t^{2}-t+2\right)dt=19.5,\qquad \int_{1}^{4}(4t-2)\,dt=24$$
1 markA method for the difference. Subtracting the two integrals works, or you can integrate $v_{2}-v_{1}$ in one go.
The difference is $24-19.5=4.5$.
1 markThe difference in distance. $\frac{9}{2}$ is fine.
Answer
The second object travels 4.5 m further.
The full walkthrough of 2025 Paper 1, Question 18 goes through it mark by mark.